September 23, 2002
Mike Hannemann is working on a special purpose Lisp plugin for Eclipse.
For Java, eclipse
just rules. It took me 10 minutes of using emacs on the mac to miss
it. Compiling files when you save them (so you don't have to use
batch files or recompile everything), context awareness, little
lightbulbs when you declare imports but don't use them, ability to
quick-fix everything from used-but-not imported code to adding things
to .cvsignore ... It's just nice.
For lisp here, it's unclear. But the next big thing on the agenda is
a display of the current CERA event
recognizer state -- i.e., what patterns are active, and where they
are. Yes, you could add that to Emacs too, with graphics and mouse
events and everything, but...
An editor with a nice extendable GUI is a powerful thing.
Posted by jjwiseman at September 23, 2002 10:38 AM
Did I mention that Eclipse just rules? CVS integration. Javadoc context support. Refactoring. All the customizable highlighting & tab settings you could want. The ability to associate source files with java classes, so you can say "what does this really do?" on a piece of arbitrary java code, and it can open up the java.util.Vector source for you. The ability to evaluate snippets of code without building an entire framework and running a program to test something. A Lisp-style Java object inspector. An outline view of code blocks (because it's Java-structure aware). Dependency tracking and automatic classpath fixing. Javadoc comment generation.
It does everything but warn you that you're writing in sentence fragments. And I bet I could add a plug-in for that...
I tried Eclipse (for Java), but I couldn't figure out a way to get it to auto-format code without reformatting the entire file. That's enough to make me unwilling to use it. Can this be done, without writing a plug-in? The features look pretty interesting, but if it can't compete with Emacs in the convenience of editing arena, the cost is too high.
Did you try selecting the region you want to format, right-clicking, and choosing "Format" from the context menu?
I didn't actually know that was there until I went looking for it, but it seems to work for me. The only caveat is that all indentation is relative to the previous spot. If you select a range, tab three times to indent the block so that it's sitting in the middle of your editor window, and format it, nothing will happen. If you select your indented text and include a bit of text above which is supposed to be at the same indentation level, then it'll move your code back so it's all nicely aligned.
(If that's not what you meant by autoformat, let me know.)
If you're judging it, make sure you're using the latest main release, currently 2.0.1. There are small but important increases in usability even over 2.0.
For myself, I can't go back to writing Java in an editor which can't peer into the classes for me. It's not worth it.
So where (or when) is the lisp plugin available? I'm a pretty big fan of emacs but I've been spending some time in IntelliJ's IDEA. Alas, IDEA is a commercial product and only does Java. Eclipse, on the other hand, isn't and does more; quite attractive. Thanks.
I'm going to study common lisp and since I'm using eclipse to develop java project I'd like to try your plugin so that I don't have to use another ide. Where can I find it?
Amazingly enough, you're the second person to ask about this in as many days. The short story is that the project we built this for is complete, and I'm in a position to strip out the project-specific bits and open-source the rest. I'll post here (and send mail) when this is done.
For someone new to lisp, I think I'd say that this is _not_ an excellent IDE, merely a sufficiently functional one. Our use in doing it was to write other Eclipse modules which were specific to the Lisp program running on the other side, so we could graph data, examine work-flow, and more -- things that I still believe would have been more difficult to do in (X)Emacs (though easier in one of the CLIM environments). Without those, you still have CVS integration, project management, and all that, but for myself, I prefer the Emacs-y route.
(Of course, by open-sourcing it, that means someone else could improve upon the Lisp experience if they felt the need.)
where is the url for downloading the plugin lisp for eclipse please !!
I think it's clear there is a CLAMOR for lisp inside eclipse.
Let me add myself to the crowd!
WHen is it going to be available?
Thanks in advance.
I've just switched to Eclipse 2.1 for Java development. I love the integration of CVS and JUnit. ALso using the Omondo UML plug-in and a profiler that does most things JProbe does, for free. Strangely, I was just wishing there was a Lisp plug-in when I spotted this post...
Yowza! Okay, okay. I've got some free time now; I'll sourceforge this as soon as possible.
Add me also to the list of interested people :)
I also would really like to use the Lisp plugin for eclipse!!
I couldn't find in on sourceforge as of 9/4/03.
clamor clamor clamor
Has this code been made available?
Any update on when the plugin will be availble? I would be happy to test it...
Clamour clamour! I want it too!
I like to add myself to the ever increasing crowd interested in using the lisp plugin
I apologize for not releasing this earlier this year; Eclipse had come out with a new version of the editor, and I wanted to make sure the undocumented API calls I'd used for a few things still worked. This still needs to be done, of course.
Now, I'm mostly of the opinion that no one really wants this, even if you think you do. What I did wasn't as featureful as (portable-) eli, Ilisp, Hemlock, Lispwork's IDE, SLIME, MCL, etc.; the only reason for doing it at all was that we could then add Java-based visualization and logging tools. As Lisp IDEs go, I definitely perfer Emacs. =) But, I'll try to package it all up so you can see this for yourselves.
Let me add another vote for this :)
"I'm mostly of the opinion that no one really wants this, even if you think you do."
I think we do want it - I work in a research group and our codebase is a grand mixture of Java and Lisp with everything stored in CVS.
So it would be great if we could work on Java files and Lisp files within the same IDE and also take advantage of Eclipse's great (IMHO) CVS integration...
Even just being able to match parens within the LISP files would be a huge help to us :)
I want it. If you don't do it, I'll do it.
I'm a professional Java developer, currently using the Eclipse platform (if you can call it that at 2.1), implementing plug-ins. I also want to learn LISP. I'm too lazy to go back to Emacs (and haven't you heard, Eclipse is the Java version of Emacs :-).
I have hacked together a little Lisp editor for Eclipse over the weekend. All it does right now is rudimentary syntax colouring. I'll post it on my website soon.
I'll work on bracket matching next.
The reasons it hasn't been forthcoming are a) I've been busy, b) some of the API calls I was using weren't public, so I wanted to correct them in case they didn't work with v3, and c) I wanted to strip out some of the bits that were project-specific here before releasing it into the wild.
a) is still a lame but good reason, I think. I'm not sure that b) and c) are necessary, though. If you're serious about wanting it, and wanting to work on it, I think I can package up something to send you.
Alternately, if you don't want to piece together my Eclipse plugin after I tear various bits out of it, I can just send you things like the bracket matching code I wrote/used/stole.
I hope you didn't take my comment as criticism. I know very well the situation you're in, and it isn't any easier when you have to strip in the bits that the public isn't meant to see (it's nice enough of your employer to let you open-source the Lisp-part).
For the moment I happen to have some spare time and motivation to get the Lisp-Plugin rolling. Any code snippets I can steal will be highly appreciated. I'm not sure what license I'll use; I'll make sure to think about it *before* I actually put *source* code on my site. That's mainly why I have only released the binary so far.
So do send something my way (I'll send an email to you with my address); I can even strip out the "bad bits" myself. I will definitely not use any eclipse.internal calls, so if you have a lot of those, I may throw some of your code away, but I'm sure I can use some of it.
FYI, I've been talking with Nicolai, and have happily given over the Java source for my Eclipse Lisp plugin. He's already incorporated the bracket-matching code, and I think this is great.
I told him that I could also give him my Lisp REPL code ... but that there are probably better ones out there in the community already. I didn't know of any at the time, so I wrote something which established multiple TCP connections (one for eval/response, one for control, one for my extra logging window) and did the job adequately, if not well. So, maybe someone else will be willing to proffer up code for that when the time comes.
But anyway. Go Nicolai!
So what's the status now??? Thx...
Please, this would be awesome! When will it be available?
Wooo! This sounds exciting.. eclipse is very nice; a lisp plugin would be cool.
I don't really know what the latest status is; I haven't talked to Nicolai Czempin in quite some time (since there was no reason for me to after I handed the project off).
My impression from his blog, last I read it, was that he'd gotten distracted by shinier things. But anyone interested should find him and write to ask. Maybe he'll pass the torch once again.
I haven't updated the plug-in since way back in 2004. Interest always seemed to be marginal. I have received one e-mail over the years.
Eclipse seems to be picking up in popularity; apparently RCP development is starting to come under the Radar of prospective clients of mine; continuing work on the plug-in is always under consideration for me.
However, if anyone were to ask me if he could wake up the project from hiatus, I wouldn't mind; the source is available and no-one's stopping you from taking over.
I will eventually pick up work on it again, I just can't say when. I was actually very close in my last project which involved Eclipse RCP coaching with marginal relations to the AutoCAD environment (which uses Lisp), but sadly it didn't materialize.
So unless I get more chances to work on this in the context of an actual project, you'll have to keep in mind that this is only a part-time hobby for me.
I too would like to have a LISP plugin for Eclipse. Thanks.
(Anyway, visitng your blog, to see what I can get ;-))
I can't stand Emacs and would be interested in working on the Eclipse plugin. Where's the source?
I have been looking for a lisp plugin for eclipse for the longest time, and I always end up in your website, yet since I see that it has been dead for a while I never leave messages, as I imagene many others do, (you are still the number one search for lisp eclipse) so if you need to feel interest to get back on track mention it in the top and I am sure you will get alot of messages from more people